• Finding the perfect vegan cheese for pizza can be challenging, but we've done the taste-testing for you!
  • Top vegan cheeses for pizza include Miyoko's Creamery Organic Cashew Milk Mozzarella and Daiya Mozzarella Style Shreds.
  • Consider factors like meltability, flavor, and environmental impact when choosing a vegan cheese.
  • Take a fun quiz to find your ideal vegan cheese based on your taste preferences and pizza personality.

Imagine a golden crust, the aroma of tomato sauce, and gooey cheese stretching with every slice. Pizza night is a sacred tradition in many households, but for those of us embracing a vegan lifestyle, the quest for the perfect cheese alternative can feel like searching for a dairy-free needle in a haystack. Fear not, fellow plant-based pioneers! We've taken on the noble task of taste-testing an array of vegan cheeses to crown the ultimate topping for your next pizza extravaganza.

Cheese That Melts Your Heart (Not the Polar Ice Caps)

When it comes to pizza, not just any vegan cheese will do. It must have that quintessential meltability factor, coupled with a flavor that complements rather than competes with your favorite toppings. The environmental impact is also crucial—after all, what's the point of choosing vegan if it's not eco-friendly? We've considered these factors and more in our search for a cheese that satisfies both palate and planet.

Top Vegan Cheeses

  1. Miyoko's Creamery Organic Cashew Milk Mozzarella
    Miyoko's Creamery Organic Cashew Milk Mozzarella - Praised for its superb meltability and rich flavor, perfect for a classic pizza experience.
  2. Violife Just Like Mozzarella Shreds
    Violife Just Like Mozzarella Shreds - Known for its creamy texture and great taste that complements any pizza topping.
  3. Daiya Mozzarella Style Shreds
    Daiya Mozzarella Style Shreds - A fan favorite for those who love a gooey, stretchy cheese with a balanced flavor profile.
  4. Follow Your Heart Vegan Gourmet Mozzarella
    Follow Your Heart Vegan Gourmet Mozzarella - Offers a melty and delicious option that's also soy-free, for those with dietary restrictions.
  5. So Delicious Dairy Free Mozzarella Shreds
    So Delicious Dairy Free Mozzarella Shreds - Made from coconut milk, these shreds are ideal for the health-conscious pizza lover.
  6. Good Planet Foods Mozzarella
    Good Planet Foods Mozzarella - This allergen-free cheese melts beautifully and has a mild, versatile flavor for all types of pizzas.

The Slice-by-Slice Breakdown

Let's cut right to the chase. We sampled numerous brands and varieties—from artisanal cashew spreads to high-tech coconut oil concoctions—to bring you an honest breakdown of each contender. Texture, taste complexity, and how well they brown under the broiler are just some of the criteria we evaluated. And because we know that one person's mozzarella is another's provolone, diversity in flavor profiles was also on our checklist.

Vegan Cheese Showdown: Brand Performance Across Testing Criteria

But before we dive into our findings, let's take a moment to appreciate the journey vegan cheese has undergone. Once notorious for its plastic-like consistency and peculiar aftertaste, today's options are nothing short of revolutionary. With advancements in food science and a surge in demand for plant-based products, we're witnessing an era where vegan cheese stands tall alongside its dairy counterparts.

Finding Your Perfect Vegan Cheese Match

Your ideal pizza night cheese may be as unique as your topping preferences—whether you're all about classic Margherita or you fancy adventurous combos like barbecue jackfruit with pineapple. To help narrow down your choices, consider taking a fun quiz designed to pair you with your dream dairy-free delight based on your taste preferences and pizza personality.

The Ultimate Vegan Cheese Pizza Quiz

Are you a pizza aficionado with a penchant for plant-based perfection? Test your knowledge and find the best vegan cheese for your pizza preferences with our quiz!

Now that you're equipped with some preliminary insights into what makes a great vegan pizza cheese, let’s prepare our palates for an adventure through creamy havens and tangy treasures. Stay tuned as we delve deeper into our top picks and uncover hidden gems that could elevate your next homemade pie from simply satisfying to sublimely sensational.

The Proof is in the Pizza: Real-World Testing

We didn't stop at mere theory; we put these cheeses to the ultimate test—a live pizza-making session where each candidate had its moment under the spotlight (or rather, in the oven). From preheat to plate, we scrutinized how these cheeses behaved in real-world conditions because there's no better test than seeing if they can handle the heat.

The Ultimate Vegan Cheese Pizza Showdown

a kitchen counter with pizza-making tools and a variety of vegan cheeses
Assembling Your Pizza-Making Arsenal
Begin your vegan cheese adventure by gathering all the necessary tools and ingredients. You'll need a pizza stone or baking sheet, a rolling pin, your favorite pizza dough, sauce, and a variety of vegan cheeses to test. Opt for a mix of shreds, slices, and soft cheeses to fully explore the spectrum of vegan cheese possibilities.
hands rolling pizza dough on a floured surface with a hot oven in the background
Preheat and Prep
Crank up your oven to the highest setting, typically around 475-500°F (245-260°C), to mimic a traditional pizza oven. While it's heating, roll out your dough on a floured surface to your desired thickness, then transfer it to a cornmeal-dusted pizza peel or parchment paper for easy sliding onto your pizza stone or baking sheet.
spreading sauce on pizza dough with a sprinkle of vegan cheese
Sauce and Base Cheese Layer
Spread your pizza sauce evenly, leaving a small border for the crust. Then, sprinkle a base layer of a neutral-flavored vegan cheese to create a melty foundation. This will help you assess how additional cheese varieties blend and melt together during baking.
pizza dough divided into sections with different types of vegan cheese on each
The Great Vegan Cheese Experiment
Now for the fun part! Section your pizza dough into wedges without cutting through, assigning each wedge to a different vegan cheese. Be generous and creative—mix shreds with slices or dollops of soft cheese. Label each section if necessary, so you can track which cheese melts and bubbles to perfection.
pizza with various vegan cheeses baking in a hot oven
Into the Fiery Depths
Carefully slide your pizza onto the preheated stone or baking sheet. Bake until the crust is golden and the cheese has reached your desired level of gooeyness or crispiness. This could take anywhere from 5 to 15 minutes depending on your oven and the thickness of your dough.
a freshly baked pizza with different melted vegan cheeses ready to taste
The Moment of Truth
Once baked to perfection, remove your pizza from the oven and let it cool for a few minutes. This is crucial for the cheese to set and for you to avoid a molten mouthful. Slice through the sections and serve. Observe the melt, stretch, and flavor profile of each cheese as you taste. Take notes on your favorites for your next pizza night!

In anticipation of revealing our top selections for your next pizza night, remember that exploring vegan alternatives is about more than just finding replacements—it’s about discovering new flavors and textures that could redefine your culinary experiences. So whether you’re looking forward to hosting a plant-based party or just enjoying a quiet evening at home with a slice in hand,

The Melting Point: Vegan Cheese That Won’t Let You Down

Now, let's talk about melting. It's the heartthrob of pizza night. The right vegan cheese should not only taste good but also melt into that delectable gooeyness we all crave. Some plant-based cheeses have a reputation for being stubborn in the melt department, but fear not! Innovations have brought us several brands that turn into a molten river of joy under the right heat.

For those who want to witness this magic happen before their eyes, I've captured the transformation of several top contenders in a melt-test video. Watching these vegan cheeses go from solid to sublime will surely get your appetite going.

Nutritional Profile: Because Health Matters Too

While indulging in pizza is often more about pleasure than nutrition, it’s reassuring to know what you’re putting into your body. Vegan cheeses are diverse in their ingredients, with some being nut-based, others soy-based, and still others using root vegetables or coconut oil. Each comes with its own set of nutritional benefits and considerations.

For those who are health-conscious or have dietary restrictions, I've compiled a nutritional comparison chart. This chart offers a glance at calories, fats, proteins, and any added nutrients like vitamin B12 or calcium. It's important to choose a vegan cheese that aligns with your dietary needs without compromising on taste.

Nutritional Comparison of Popular Vegan Cheeses

The Final Verdict: Top Picks for Your Pizza Party

After extensive tasting and testing for flavor, texture, meltability, and nutritional value, it's time to reveal the crème de la crème of vegan cheeses for pizza. These brands have consistently stood out from the pack and have earned their spot on our recommended list.

Remember that finding your favorite may require some experimentation. Palates differ and what might be my top pick could come second to another's preference. So don't shy away from trying different brands or even blending them for a more complex flavor profile on your pizza.

If you're curious about how well you know your vegan cheese flavors or want to discover which type suits your palate best before buying, take this fun quiz!

The Ultimate Vegan Cheese Taste Test

Do you consider yourself a connoisseur of vegan cheese? Put your taste buds to the test with our quiz on the flavor profiles of various vegan cheeses. Whether you're prepping for your next pizza night or just want to expand your dairy-free cheese knowledge, this quiz is for you!

To round off your perfect pizza night with something sweet, why not explore some delightful vegan desserts? Find out which dessert could be your match made in heaven with this interactive quiz:

Find Your Vegan Dessert Match

Are you curious about which vegan dessert might be your perfect match for a sweet treat after a pizza night? Take this quiz to discover which plant-based delight aligns with your taste preferences!

In conclusion (though we promised not to say it), whether you're hosting a big gathering or enjoying a solo night in with a movie and comfort food, the right vegan cheese can make all the difference. It’s about finding that balance between ethical eating and indulgent flavors—a quest that is both noble and delicious!

And remember, if you ever find yourself craving more than just homemade delights, our guides can help you navigate through the best vegan restaurants, or check out recommended dishes to judge their quality.

Keep exploring, keep tasting, and let every pizza night be an adventure in compassionate culinary delight.

To further enhance your vegan lifestyle journey beyond pizza night, dive into our articles like top food hacks, discover which foods surprisingly taste better when they’re vegan, or test your knowledge with our fun quizzes on NYC vegan restaurants trivia and plant-based substitutes.

Recommended Products

365 By Whole Foods Market, Cheese Non Dairy Cheddar Shreds, 8 Ounce Our Recommendation
365 By Whole Foods Market, Cheese Non Dairy Cheddar Shreds, 8 Ounce
4.4 (96+ Reviews)
$3.49
Violife Just Like Mexican Shreds, Vegan, 8 oz Bag Our Recommendation
Violife Just Like Mexican Shreds, Vegan, 8 oz Bag
4.7 (491+ Reviews)
$5.49
Dairy Free Cheese, Vegan Mozzarella Cheese That Melts Perfectly, Healthy Plant Based Cheese, 7 oz Bag of Vegan Cheese Shredded, Lactose Free Cheese with No Allergens, Non Dairy Cheese. Our Recommendation
Dairy Free Cheese, Vegan Mozzarella Cheese That Melts Perfectly, Healthy Plant Based Cheese, 7 oz Bag of Vegan Cheese Shredded, Lactose Free Cheese with No Allergens, Non Dairy Cheese.
4.3 (37+ Reviews)
$6.79
MIYOKO'S CREAMERY Fresh Vegan Mozzarella, Organic Classic Plant Milk Cheese, Dairy Free, 8 oz. (1-pack) Our Recommendation
MIYOKO'S CREAMERY Fresh Vegan Mozzarella, Organic Classic Plant Milk Cheese, Dairy Free, 8 oz. (1-pack)
4.5 (2550+ Reviews)
$8.79
Field Roast Chao Creamery Vegan Shreds, Creamy Original, Alternative Cheese, 7 Oz Our Recommendation
Field Roast Chao Creamery Vegan Shreds, Creamy Original, Alternative Cheese, 7 Oz
4.6 (420+ Reviews)
$5.79
Daiya, Dairy Free Mozzarella Style Vegan Cheese Shreds, 7.1 Ounce Our Recommendation
Daiya, Dairy Free Mozzarella Style Vegan Cheese Shreds, 7.1 Ounce
4.5 (2586+ Reviews)
$4.69
Daiya Dairy Free Mozzarella Style Vegan Cheese Sticks Our Recommendation
Daiya Dairy Free Mozzarella Style Vegan Cheese Sticks
4.1 (122+ Reviews)
$5.99
VIOlife Just Like Colby Jack Shreds, 8 Oz Bag, 8 Oz Our Recommendation
VIOlife Just Like Colby Jack Shreds, 8 Oz Bag, 8 Oz
4.6 (3787+ Reviews)
$5.29
MIYOKO'S CREAMERY Organic Pourable Mozzarella Cheese, Melts-Bubbles-Browns, Made from Plant Milk, Dairy Free, Vegan, 16oz. (1-Pack) Our Recommendation
MIYOKO'S CREAMERY Organic Pourable Mozzarella Cheese, Melts-Bubbles-Browns, Made from Plant Milk, Dairy Free, Vegan, 16oz. (1-Pack)
4.6 (84+ Reviews)
$7.69
VIOLIFE Just Like Mozzarella Shreds, 8 OZ Our Recommendation
VIOLIFE Just Like Mozzarella Shreds, 8 OZ
4.6 (5482+ Reviews)
$5.29
365 By Whole Foods Market, Cheese Non Dairy Mozzarella Shreds, 8 Ounce Our Recommendation
365 By Whole Foods Market, Cheese Non Dairy Mozzarella Shreds, 8 Ounce
4.4 (89+ Reviews)
$3.49
Daiya Zesty Cheddar Vegan Cheese Sauce, Dairy Free Vegan Queso Dip (Pack of 1) Our Recommendation
Daiya Zesty Cheddar Vegan Cheese Sauce, Dairy Free Vegan Queso Dip (Pack of 1)
4.3 (2835+ Reviews)
$12.60 Prime Eligible
NOOCH IT! Fair Trade Dairy-Free Cashew Grated Cheeze | Vegan Parmesan ● Tasty Cheese Alternative | 4oz (Vegan "Parm", Gluten-Free) Our Recommendation
NOOCH IT! Fair Trade Dairy-Free Cashew Grated Cheeze | Vegan Parmesan ● Tasty Cheese Alternative | 4oz (Vegan "Parm", Gluten-Free)
4.4 (3314+ Reviews)
$10.99 Prime Eligible
Farmer Foodie | Italian Herb | Vegan Dairy-Free Cashew Parmesan Cheese Alternative | Grated | Gluten-Free | 3.2 oz Jar with Pour & Sprinkle Cap Our Recommendation
Farmer Foodie | Italian Herb | Vegan Dairy-Free Cashew Parmesan Cheese Alternative | Grated | Gluten-Free | 3.2 oz Jar with Pour & Sprinkle Cap
4.5 (77+ Reviews)
$11.99 Prime Eligible
Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Pizza Sauce, 15 Ounce (Pack of 1) Our Recommendation
Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Pizza Sauce, 15 Ounce (Pack of 1)
4.4 (2805+ Reviews)
$0.81 Prime Eligible
Daiya, Dairy Free Cutting Board Cheddar Style Vegan Cheese Shreds, 7.1 Ounce Our Recommendation
Daiya, Dairy Free Cutting Board Cheddar Style Vegan Cheese Shreds, 7.1 Ounce
4.5 (2965+ Reviews)
$4.69
Vegan Magic Cheese Sauce (6oz powder makes 16oz cheese sauce), Cheddar Cheese Powder for Vegan, Plant-Based Cheese, Nacho Dipping Sauce, Mac & Cheese, Salty Crackers Dairy Free, Low Sodium Our Recommendation
Vegan Magic Cheese Sauce (6oz powder makes 16oz cheese sauce), Cheddar Cheese Powder for Vegan, Plant-Based Cheese, Nacho Dipping Sauce, Mac & Cheese, Salty Crackers Dairy Free, Low Sodium
4.1 (145+ Reviews)
$12.99 Prime Eligible
365 By Whole Foods Market, Cheese Non Dairy Parmesan Style Shreds, 5 Ounce Our Recommendation
365 By Whole Foods Market, Cheese Non Dairy Parmesan Style Shreds, 5 Ounce
3.9 (45+ Reviews)
$4.29
PARMELA CREAMERY Plant Based Mozzarella Shreds, 7 OZ Our Recommendation
PARMELA CREAMERY Plant Based Mozzarella Shreds, 7 OZ
4.3 (165+ Reviews)
$4.99
Whole Foods Market, Fresh Mozarella Ciliegine, 8 oz Our Recommendation
Whole Foods Market, Fresh Mozarella Ciliegine, 8 oz
4.7 (2408+ Reviews)
$4.99
Daiya, Dairy Free Gluten Free Four Cheeze Style with Herbs Vegan Mac and Cheese, 10.6 Ounce Our Recommendation
Daiya, Dairy Free Gluten Free Four Cheeze Style with Herbs Vegan Mac and Cheese, 10.6 Ounce
4.3 (338+ Reviews)
$3.97
Classico Signature Recipes Traditional Tomato Spaghetti and Pizza Sauce (14 oz Jar) Our Recommendation
Classico Signature Recipes Traditional Tomato Spaghetti and Pizza Sauce (14 oz Jar)
4.6 (3322+ Reviews)
$2.72 Prime Eligible
Nutristore Freeze Dried Mozzarella Cheese Shredded 20 Large Servings | Premium Quality | Amazing Taste | Perfect for Camping | Survival Food Our Recommendation
Nutristore Freeze Dried Mozzarella Cheese Shredded 20 Large Servings | Premium Quality | Amazing Taste | Perfect for Camping | Survival Food
4.4 (33+ Reviews)
$178.99
Daiya, Frozen, Dairy Free Gluten Free Meatless Pepperoni Vegan Pizza, 16.7 Ounce Our Recommendation
Daiya, Frozen, Dairy Free Gluten Free Meatless Pepperoni Vegan Pizza, 16.7 Ounce
4.4 (539+ Reviews)
$7.99
Ethan Reed
Sustainability, Environmental Activism, Vegan Products, Green Technology

Ethan Reed is a sustainability expert and environmental activist. He provides insights on how to live a vegan lifestyle while minimizing environmental impact. Ethan's articles on eco-friendly vegan products are highly appreciated by Lonely Vegan readers.

Post a comment

0 comments